I Killed the Tooth Fairy
A repost here at the new blog from my original (and still slowly chugging along) blog Holy Sh!+ from Deacon Blue.
Originally posted in August 2012:
I sit here now, glittery sparkling blood on my hands as I type. I can’t wash it off, any more than Lady Macbeth’s incessant hand washing could remove the memory of what horrors she had unleashed and sins she had committed. *Sigh* Where do I begin? I suppose with a simple fact. A simple statement.
This afternoon, I killed the Tooth Fairy.
Granted, I wasn’t trying to. I wanted to save her. I wanted to preserve her. But her death is now laid at my feet.
Such a sudden thing it was, too. I took my darling daughter, who just a couple weeks ago turned 7, to the children’s museum in Portland, Maine, so that our favorite grown woman (her mother, my wife) could have brunch with some people she had wanted to meet for a while. We had barely finished paying for admission and then walking to the first room in the museum when Little Girl Blue said, calmly and without preamble, “Daddy, is the Tooth Fairy real, or do you and Mommy put the money under my pillow? Please be totally honest.”
In that moment, I realized I had been asked a question only slightly less distressing to parents than “What is sex?” or “Can I get a belly button piercing?” I did not pause, but simply led her to a small bench somewhat away from the other kids, sat down with her, and asked, “Do you really want to know?”
“You’re sure you want to ask this question, even though the answer may change things in your life?”
“Yes. Please be honest.”
Twice now she had stressed honesty, and so there was no other path. Before, when a Kindergartner in her first year of school had told her the Tooth Fairy wasn’t real, Mrs. Blue simply asked, “What do you believe? What do you want to think? That’s all that matters.” My wife’s words (and clever ploy) were enough then, and they were true words, and Little Girl Blue continued to believe. Now, though, she was pressing me to be honest. I’m not sure why I drew this short straw, but I don’t think it would have been any different had my wife been the one with her at that moment; Little Girl Blue knows we’ll speak truth when asked, and most other times as well.
“Well, Honey, before I answer your question, let me ask you this: If it turns out Mommy and Daddy are the ones giving you the money, and I confirm that, do you think that there will still be money under your pillow in the future?” She was still young enough not to realize that I had essentially admitted the Tooth Fairy wasn’t real, but I was banking on that childish naivete so that she could still have an out if she wanted it.
She muddled over that for a few moments, then said, “Yes! …um, maybe not. I guess no. But I want to know.”
“I’m going to ask you one more time: Are you sure?” I queried, quietly but intently. “Sometimes, getting an honest answer to things changes things in ways you might not like. Do you still want me to answer?”
“Yes. I do.”
I put my arm around her and leaned in close, and said in almost a whisper, “No, Honey. The Tooth Fairy isn’t real. That’s Mommy and Daddy.”
“OK, Daddy,” she said after a short pause to let that sink in. “Thanks for telling me.”
“You’re welcome,” I said, and then played my last card to let magic be in her world a bit longer. “Frankly, I don’t know if any fairies are assigned any tooth-related duties. And they sure wouldn’t be carrying human money around, now would they?”
“No, they wouldn’t. I still believe in fairies, Daddy. Just not the Tooth Fairy.”
“That’s good, Honey. There are all kinds of strange and wonderful things in the world, even if they haven’t been proven they exist and even if we’ve never seen them.” Then I lowered my voice even more, and looked at the other kids in the room in a way that she couldn’t help but notice. “Don’t tell other kids, honey. Kids have told you the Tooth Fairy isn’t real, when you would have figured it out yourself someday. And you found out earlier than you probably needed to. But don’t ruin it for another kid. Let them ask the question when they’re ready to ask their parents. Some parents and kids don’t think about that; some purposely want to end that belief for other people because they think it’s stupid. So please don’t do it to anyone.”
“I won’t, Daddy.”
I thought I was done until later in our children’s museum visit, when we were sitting down to a snack and she asked, “Are there any other magical things in my life that you and Mommy have told me about that aren’t real?”
Shit. So soon? The dominoes all ready to fall, all at once, on the same day?
“Do you have a specific question?”
“Are any other magical things in my life that aren’t real?”
“No, do you have a question about some specific thing?”
“I can’t think of one right now. But are there any other things?”
I paused only a moment, torn about what I should do, and then said, “I’m not going to answer that question. It’s too broad. Honey, we’ve had to tell you about horrible things sometimes, like people who hurt kids and people who kill people for no good reason. We’ve had to let you know about some bad things in life, and I think you should have as much magic as you can in life. For as long as you can. If you have a question about a specific thing, you can ask Mommy or me about it, and we’ll be truthful. But I won’t answer the question you just asked. But you can ask the questions about each thing as you want to. When you want to.”
“OK, Daddy. Thank you for being honest.”
And so, Santa Claus, the Birthday Fairy (Akimahs), the Leprechaun and the Easter Bunny have a reprieve. Not sure how long, but for a little while, at least.
It may seem weird, but I do feel guilty about the Tooth Fairy’s demise. My honesty killed her, and no matter how much that honesty was needed then, I still feel bad. That bit of magic is fun for the parents and the kids. The loss of that magic is a sign of my daughter’s maturity, and that’s a good thing; it warms my heart. But at the same time, it’s bittersweet. It makes me mourn for her childhood already, knowing that it is fast receding the closer she gets to tween and teen years.
But she still believes in fairies; that’s good. Mrs. Blue does, too, more or less. And we all believe in angels, because we’ve known at times when they’ve moved in our lives. So, it’s not all bad.
But Santa, Leprechaun, Easter Bunny and Akimahs: Draw up your wills and settle any unfinished business now.
You may not be long for Little Girl Blue’s world.
(Oh, by the way, since I wrote the post above in August 2012, the Leprechaun died in similar manner by November or December. So far, all the other beings are alive, though some of them on life-support, I suspect…)
P.S. If you think my bloody chalk outline of the tooth fairy is slightly grim, that’s OK. At least I didn’t go as far as this…or that…or the other one over here.
Posted on March 4, 2013, in Conversations with my daughter and tagged easter bunny, fairies, leprechaun, magic, santa, tooth fairy. Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.
Daddy you know that she is placating you right? The first domino fell – they are all down now but she doesn’t want to hurt your feelings.
Well, I suspect as much, but we humans are great at self-delusion and denial, so she *might* still believe. Hard to tell. In any case, probably not trying to spare my feelings; more likely, she’s trying to continue to secure gifts/treats (we wouldn’t stop Xmas and Easter gifts/treats anyway, even if she stopped believing in Santa and Easter Bunny, but she might not know that yet) 😉